|
In most cases there are actually few problems for pensions. One problem they face is that in most cases pensions are not fully indexed to the cost of living. And inflation in the costs faced by pensioners (drugs, housing nursing care, energy, transportation) is likely far higher than indicated by the consumer price index. The consumer price index is driven down by price deflation in many manufactured items including consumer electronics. But many pensioners may not be buying these discretionary items. Most pensioners do not have to worry that their pension benefits will be reduced. If a pension deficit develops it is normally current and future employees as well as the employer that has to make up the deficit over a period of years. However, in rare cases, pensioners do have to worry that their pensions could be reduced. If a corporation with a pension deficit becomes bankrupt then there would normally still be segregated pension assets to draw upon. But if there is a pension deficit then this would normally trigger a reduction in benefits. (Unless the government or a pension insurance fund steps in to cover the losses)
A major problem for corporations and investors is that pension accounting results in very volatile amounts for pension expenses. If the pension assets perform well, then the pension expense is lower and vice-a-versa. And this occurs even though changes in pension assets and liabilities are largely smoothed by amortising certain changes over many years. If the annual change in the net funded position of the pension was immediately recognized on the balance sheet and flowed to net income, then the volatility in pension expenses would become extremely volatile. Since accounting rules in general appear to be becoming more conservative, it is possible that such an accounting change could be made. (In that case it would be necessary for analysts to adjust the pension expense to a normalised level). Pension expenses and company contributions, aside from being volatile have also increased rapidly which is reducing net income. Many corporations (and therefore shareholders) face unfunded liabilities in the pension that may or may not be recorded on the balance sheet.
A big problem for current employees is that pension contributions have been rising rapidly. Required pension contributions have increased as the assumption regarding the return on plan assets has decreased (probably without a corresponding decrease in the assumptions regarding wage increases.) The required contribution has also increased due to longer life expectancies. In addition in cases where unfunded liabilities exist, current employees are facing higher contributions to make up for past contributions that a were, in retrospect, too low. There are some real horror stories regarding contributions. Alberta teachers are currently contributing about 12% of wages, while their employers contribute 14%. This total of 26% is partly caused by a pension deficit. In any event this is a horrendous level of pension contributions and is close to 3 times higher than the total contributions of about 8% to 10% that were considered standard, just a few years ago. For more information on the woes of pension plans see my updated pension article. END If you like the analysis in this newsletter and on this site, and are investing in stocks, then (if you have not already done so) consider subscribing to our stock research service for just $10 per month (and you can cancel anytime).
|
|